Never Quit - Just Walk Away

"On Track" 24 x 36 Oil on Linen
Whether I'm outside painting Plein Air or in the studio, making the intellectual decision to conclude the current painting can be as daunting as knowing when to stand up and walk away from the three card poker table in the Bellagio while "still up" and winning. Damn the difference...
When painting outside on site, I have a constant friend that can help make the decision to stop - The Sun. Apollo doesn't wait for anyone and neither does his Sun. Its ever-changing position in the sky from East to West causes the light cast on a Plein Air subject to change dramatically within a couple of hours. This is the stopwatch alarm for me. When the shadow of an old beat up truck is now on the left side after it was on the right side when you started, and all the brilliant light has shifted as well, it's time to go to another site, pack it up and crack a beer or just go home. The beauty of Plein Air painting is one has to paint fast to capture the light that caught the eye in the first place. The race is on and this makes the artist fast, loose and such a better painter when back in the studio. If that light has significantly changed, and we're still painting, unless we're painting from memory, we're going to get in trouble as all the values and temperatures that composed the subject in the beginning have gone, and now we're painting an entirely different composition. Throw your cards down, cash in your chips and walk away..... It's time. If we've limited ourselves to the Sun's pace, again around two to three hours, and we've quickly blocked in the painting at the beginning, the painting should be done anyway and free from being overworked.
One can always finish the painting in the studio, but for someone like me with just enough ADHD and possibly already in the cooler digging out a post-painting beer, breaking out the painting again that night ain't gonna happen. Taking a Plein Air painting back to the studio to "touch up" can destroy the spontaneity and looseness of the original pass. If a painting of a rusty boat is finished on a rickety dock in the marina, the viewer of the finished work can hear the gulls, hear the ropes clinging against the sailboat masts, smell the fish heads, and feel the breeze under the hot humid canopy of the shading live oaks. Its hard to duplicate that in the studio. I always leave the gnats stuck in my wet paintings.
Knowing when to walk away from a studio painting is a whole different animal. Sometimes you'll get lucky like I did last night when two friends showed up with a case of beer just around the time I was about to enter the danger zone of overworking my latest painting "On Track". I had one beer while finishing up the abstract hounds, as my less passionate company was ready to go upstairs and insisted the painting was done. Thirsty beer drinkers can instantly become expert art critics if their beer is getting hot.
When friends aren't around to lure me to the bar, I keep a Plein Air mindset in Studio. Keep it loose, spontenaous and try to finish it Alla Prima - wet on wet all in one session. My patience and attention span or lack of thereof drives that desire to get it done. Don't rush it or cut corners, but don't overwork it. If one makes the commitment to render her subject artistically and loosely rather than duplicate it by overworking it, then her own voice will determine the end. Overworking a painting is arrogant and rude. By overworking the composition, we're telling the viewer that he or she is incapable of identifying the subject matter and we are the anointed ones who have to spell it out to the less refined. This takes away from the focal point as well and makes it hard for the viewer to figure out what was important to us - what made us choose that painting in the first place. The viewer has to be able to participate in the painting too - much like a fan at a rock concert or basketball game. Don't be arrogant. Put the brush down and sign it.
I'm not an art major, so I'm not sure who coined the most influential statement to me on this subject. I originally heard it from the late Ken Auster when I asked the question one day, "when do you know when to quit?"
He answered, " A wise artist once said, 'You never quit a painting. You abandon it after the story is told.' "
Leave a Comment